Careers & University / Big Questions / Choosing a subject
From the research interviews we hold · updated 09 Nov 2026
The research here mostly agrees that arts and humanities study is worthwhile, but for reasons that are broader than a first job. It shows these subjects build critical thinking, engagement with the world, and interdisciplinary skills, while also warning that narrow vocational measures can undervalue them.
The research we hold mostly agrees on this, so you won't see much disagreement below. That is a finding too.
Word for word, from interviews with the researchers. Each opens the moment they say it.
Getting students to engage with knowledge is about transforming who they are and how they engage with the world, and universities have an educational responsibility to design experiences that convey what this knowledge can do for students and who they can become.Paul Wiliam Ashwin, Lancaster University — Transforming University Education · 4:09
Universities marginalize Asian studies because accreditation and learning outcomes measure short-term vocational skills, whereas Asian studies develops critical thinking over decades and lacks a vocational endpoint.Anne Cullen, Griffith University — Australia's Asia Engagement: The Divide Between Asian Studies and Business Schools · 1:33
The methods of cultural studies bring literature into the world and the world into literature, invigorating the classroom by enabling different questions to be asked.Moberley Luger, University of British Columbia — Beyond Dead Poets Society · 3:04
Artistic research is wrongly dismissed as subjective, idiosyncratic, and unsuitable for scientific inquiry.Urs Bette, University of Adelaide — Architecture in Dialogue with an Activated Ground · 1:08
Early specialisation, while important for depth, has often prevented students from moving across from their home discipline into other disciplines and strengthening their knowledge of the home discipline by encountering the other discipline.Dilly Fung, University College London — A Connected Curriculum for Higher Education · 8:42
Public discourses of higher education focus on the economic benefits of going to university.Paul Wiliam Ashwin, Lancaster University — Transforming University Education · 0:35
Most of the evidence here supports studying arts and humanities, but it supports them in a particular way. It argues for their value in thinking, understanding and personal development rather than in a single job title at the end.
Finding [10] makes the broadest case. It says engaging with knowledge changes who students are and how they engage with the world, and that universities should design experiences around that. That is a strong argument for subjects that ask big questions about culture, meaning and society. Finding [5] shows one mechanism: cultural studies methods bring literature into the world and the world into literature, so the classroom asks different questions. Finding [28] pushes back on a common criticism, arguing that artistic research is wrongly dismissed as subjective and unsuitable for scientific inquiry. Together these suggest arts and humanities develop forms of inquiry that are rigorous but not always measured by standard tests.
Finding [14] adds a warning about how universities judge value. It says Asian studies gets marginalised because accreditation and learning outcomes reward short-term vocational skills, while Asian studies develops critical thinking over decades and has no vocational endpoint. That is a direct argument that the worth of these degrees is real but poorly captured by short-term employment measures.
Two findings complicate the picture. Finding [15] says early specialisation can stop students moving between disciplines and strengthening their home discipline by encountering another. That cuts against a narrow single-subject arts degree, not against arts study itself, so it is mixed. Finding [20] notes that public talk about university focuses on economic benefits. That is not evidence against arts degrees, but it explains why the debate often feels one-sided: the measures used favour vocational outcomes.
Why might researchers disagree? They study different things. Some look at what students learn and become [10, 5], others at how institutions measure and fund subjects [14], and others at public discourse [20]. Different countries and systems also value different outcomes. The overall pattern is that arts and humanities are worthwhile for critical thinking, cultural understanding and personal transformation, but their value is often invisible to short-term vocational metrics.