Careers & University / Big Questions / Worth it?
From the research interviews we hold · updated 09 Nov 2026
The research here mostly agrees that graduates earn more, but the size of that advantage varies a lot by country, institution and group. Some findings show a big premium, while others show it shrinking or being small for particular graduates.
Word for word, from interviews with the researchers. Each opens the moment they say it.
High school graduates who do not attend college have lower life expectancy, lower earnings, lower satisfaction, and earn over a million dollars less than college graduates.William Tierney, University of Southern California — Academia, and the Battle for Higher Education · 18:37
The additional earnings from having a degree have decreased to nearly zero, while individuals still incur tens of thousands of pounds in debt.Hilary Cremin, University of Cambridge — Rewilding Education: Ecosystems, Inequality, and the Future of Schooling · 2:22Paper
Graduates from Group of Eight universities in Australia earn about 13% more than other graduates.Kenneth Clements, University of Western Australia — The Market for Economics and Finance PhDs · 7:52Paper
Returns to educational credentials are significantly larger than returns to high skills, so that high credentials yield preferable labor market outcomes even without high skills, while highly skilled people without high credentials are penalized in the world of work.Satoshi Araki, Lingnan University — Economic Value of Credentials and Skills · 6:17
The benefits of completing college are very large for unlikely college graduates, indicating that college reaches a more diverse population.Jennie E. Brand, University of California Los Angeles — Overcoming the Odds · 9:43Paper
Poorer students do worse in school than richer students, attaining lower A-level grades or qualifications with fewer UCAS tariff points, and are therefore more likely to enter lower-status institutions with lower entry requirements, which harms their long-term earnings because students from high-tariff institutions do better in the labor market.Anna Vignoles, University of Cambridge — Widening Participation in Higher Education: A Quantitative Analysis · 3:43
The question sounds simple, but the evidence shows the answer depends on who you are, where you study and what you measure. Several findings support the idea that graduates earn more. [4] reports that people who never attend college have lower earnings and earn over a million dollars less over a lifetime than college graduates, alongside lower life expectancy and satisfaction. [1] finds that graduates of Australia's Group of Eight universities earn about 13% more than other graduates, which suggests the type of institution matters, not just whether you have a degree. [33] adds that the benefits of finishing college are very large for people who were unlikely to graduate in the first place, so college can reach a wider group than expected. [5] argues that credentials themselves carry a big labour-market reward, even compared with high skills, meaning the certificate can matter as much as what you know.
Other findings cut against a simple yes. [2] reports that the extra earnings from a degree have fallen to nearly zero while students still take on tens of thousands of pounds of debt, which is a direct challenge to the usual graduate premium story. [31] gives a more mixed picture: poorer students tend to get lower school grades and enter lower-status institutions, and because graduates of high-tariff institutions do better in the labour market, their long-term earnings suffer. So a degree helps, but which degree and where you get it can change the size of the gain.
Why do researchers disagree? They are looking at different countries, different time periods and different groups. [1] is about Australia and compares graduates with other graduates, not with non-graduates. [2] focuses on the UK and on recent changes in the return to a degree. [4] compares college graduates with high school graduates across a lifetime, which tends to produce a large gap. [5] measures credentials against skills, a different comparison again. [31] looks at how family background and institution type shape outcomes, which can make the average premium misleading for some students. [33] shows the benefit can be largest for those least expected to finish, which is easy to miss in averages.
Taken together, the research does not say a degree is worthless or that it always pays off equally. It says the graduate earnings advantage is real in many studies, but its size depends on the country, the institution, the student's background and what you compare. That is why the same question gets different answers.