Careers & University / Big Questions / Getting in
From the research interviews we hold · updated 09 Nov 2026
Yes, your background can affect your chances, but the effect depends heavily on which part of your background and which stage of admissions you look at. The research points in different directions because it covers different countries, groups and measures, so there is no single answer.
Word for word, from interviews with the researchers. Each opens the moment they say it.
The odds of getting into one's top-choice school through appeals and waiting lists vary markedly by income, ethnicity, and prior attainment, with the odds for those in the most affluent areas being twice as high as for those in the most deprived areas, and this disadvantage gap holds at both pupil and area levels.Emily Hund, Education Policy Institute — Fair Access to Schools? The impact of the appeals and waiting list system · 6:19
Poorer students do worse in school than richer students, attaining lower A-level grades or qualifications with fewer UCAS tariff points, and are therefore more likely to enter lower-status institutions with lower entry requirements, which harms their long-term earnings because students from high-tariff institutions do better in the labor market.Anna Vignoles, University of Cambridge — Widening Participation in Higher Education: A Quantitative Analysis · 3:43
Emphasizing standardized tests misses students who do not perform well on them and raises equity concerns because test performance differs by race and family income status, such that students with low test scores but stronger grades may be shut out of programs and schools despite being more likely to succeed than some students with higher test scores.Elaine Allensworth, University of Chicago — High School GPAs and ACT Scores as Predictors of College Completion · 11:13
Lower admission rates for Asian applicants were due to preferences for legacies and athletes, which favored white applicants, not discrimination.Mitchell Chang, University of California Los Angeles — Asian Americans and affirmative action: Addressing the color of privilege · 3:34Paper
When socioeconomic background is taken into account, students from minority ethnic groups make more progress in the education system than white students.Anna Vignoles, University of Cambridge — Widening Participation in Higher Education: A Quantitative Analysis · 2:17
Students with a low likelihood of attending selective colleges experience the largest returns to attendance, even larger than those for more advantaged students with a higher likelihood.Jennie E. Brand, University of California Los Angeles — Overcoming the Odds · 0:34Paper
The question splits into two parts: does background shape who gets offered a place, and does it shape what happens after? Most of the evidence says yes to the first, but not always in the way people assume.
Start with income. [5] found that the odds of getting into a top-choice school through appeals and waiting lists are about twice as high for applicants from the most affluent areas as for those from the most deprived, and the gap holds at both pupil and area level. [29] explains one route: poorer students tend to get lower A-level grades and fewer UCAS points, so they enter lower-status institutions with lower entry requirements, which then affects earnings. That is a chain of disadvantage running from school results to admissions to later pay.
[22] adds a mechanism. Relying heavily on standardised tests raises equity concerns because scores differ by race and family income, and students with strong grades but weaker test scores can be shut out even when they are more likely to succeed. So the way admissions measures people can itself favour some backgrounds.
But not every finding points the same way. [1] argues that lower admission rates for Asian applicants at one university were driven by preferences for legacies and athletes, which favoured white applicants, rather than direct discrimination against Asian applicants. That cuts against a simple story that background always works against minority applicants. [4] is mixed: once socioeconomic background is accounted for, students from minority ethnic groups actually make more progress in education than white students, so ethnicity alone is not a straightforward penalty. [7] is also mixed: students with a low likelihood of attending a selective college gain the largest returns from attending one, which suggests selective admission can sometimes help less advantaged students rather than only entrench advantage.
Why do researchers disagree? They study different countries with different admissions systems, different groups, and different measures. [5] looks at appeals and waiting lists in England, [1] at one US university's applicant pool, [4] at progress through school rather than offers. A finding about who gets in through a waiting list is not the same as a finding about who succeeds once admitted. Time period matters too: admissions rules and affirmative action law change. The honest summary is that background clearly matters, but the size and direction of the effect depend on which background characteristic, which institution and which stage you measure.