Careers & University / Big Questions / Worth it?
From the research interviews we hold · updated 09 Nov 2026
Yes, it matters, but less than many people assume and in ways that are not simply about prestige. The strongest evidence here is that selective or higher-tariff institutions pay off most for students who were least likely to attend them, while rankings and simple quality labels are unreliable guides.
Word for word, from interviews with the researchers. Each opens the moment they say it.
Students with a low likelihood of attending selective colleges experience the largest returns to attendance, even larger than those for more advantaged students with a higher likelihood.Jennie E. Brand, University of California Los Angeles — Overcoming the Odds · 0:34Paper
Poorer students do worse in school than richer students, attaining lower A-level grades or qualifications with fewer UCAS tariff points, and are therefore more likely to enter lower-status institutions with lower entry requirements, which harms their long-term earnings because students from high-tariff institutions do better in the labor market.Anna Vignoles, University of Cambridge — Widening Participation in Higher Education: A Quantitative Analysis · 3:43
The approximately 4,000 tertiary institutions in the United States include well-known universities like Harvard, Columbia, and USC, but these are outliers.William Tierney, University of Southern California — Academia, and the Battle for Higher Education · 8:05
University rankings dominate how the quality of different universities is thought about, yet they are misleading because they combine unrelated measures of university outputs that tend to be unrelated to educational quality into a single measure of quality.Paul Wiliam Ashwin, Lancaster University — Transforming University Education · 2:59
Personal schooling experience and personal circumstances are often more influential in determining graduate employment destinations than short-term incentives or rural experiences.Tim Fish, Monash University — I do plan to do that in the future, just not the near future · 12:09
Students with the same high school GPA or the same ACT score are more likely to graduate college if they attended some high schools than others.Elaine Allensworth, University of Chicago — High School GPAs and ACT Scores as Predictors of College Completion · 4:41
The question sounds simple, but the research splits it into two: does the institution's prestige matter, and does the specific place matter? The answers differ.
On the "yes" side, [3] finds that students with a low likelihood of attending a selective college gain the most from going to one, more than advantaged students who were always likely to attend. That suggests selectivity can be a real boost for people who beat the odds to get in. [23] adds a mechanism: poorer students tend to get lower grades, enter lower-status institutions with lower entry requirements, and earn less later, because graduates of high-tariff institutions do better in the labour market. So institution type is linked to earnings.
On the "no" or "it's overrated" side, [28] points out that famous universities like Harvard are outliers among roughly 4,000 US tertiary institutions. Most students attend places that are not famous, so generalising from elite schools distorts the picture. [33] goes further: rankings dominate how people judge university quality, but they mix unrelated output measures into one misleading number. If the ranking is not measuring educational quality, then choosing by rank is choosing on noise.
Two findings complicate the picture. [22] finds personal schooling experience and circumstances often matter more than short-term incentives or rural experiences for graduate employment destinations, suggesting the student's own path can outweigh the institution's label. [1] shows students with the same GPA or ACT score are more likely to graduate if they attended some high schools than others, which means preparation and context before university shape outcomes too, not just the university itself.
Why do researchers disagree? They study different countries, different groups, and different outcomes. [3] and [23] focus on selective or high-tariff institutions and earnings; [28] and [33] focus on the whole system and on how quality is measured. One is asking "what does an elite place add for a marginal admit?" The other is asking "is the ranking a good guide?" Both can be true. The evidence here does not support a simple prestige ladder, but it does support the idea that institution type can matter for some students, especially those for whom selective attendance is a stretch.