Careers & University / Big Questions / Getting in
From the research interviews we hold · updated 09 Nov 2026
Work experience clearly helps in some situations, but the research here shows it is not a simple pass to getting in. The findings disagree depending on whether they look at hiring, wages, or university admission, so the honest answer is that it matters differently in different contexts.
Word for word, from interviews with the researchers. Each opens the moment they say it.
The hypothesis is that legal workplace experience can be a barrier to entry and a difficult hurdle for students without it.Rob Lilley, Curtin University — What Should an 'Entry-Level Lawyer' Look Like in a Post-COVID World? · 8:12Paper
Returns to educational credentials are significantly larger than returns to high skills, so that high credentials yield preferable labor market outcomes even without high skills, while highly skilled people without high credentials are penalized in the world of work.Satoshi Araki, Lingnan University — Economic Value of Credentials and Skills · 6:17
A 10% increase in preparation for exports causes a 22 percentage point increase in the probability of hiring workers with previous experience at other exporting firms, relative to an average baseline of 19%.Claudio Labanca, Monash University — Preparing for export opportunities · 10:38
After controlling for academic performance, social class, gender, age, and ethnicity, only one element is significant in determining whether one can get the best paid job.Zhiqi Wang, Bath Spa University — Who are gaining the highly paid elite placements in UK higher education? · 4:53
Having less than three months of work in the first year was associated with an 8.5% increase in attrition.Helen Dempsey, Murdoch University — Early Career Casual Teachers: The Role of Relationships · 2:07Paper
Empirical analysis shows that the negative effect of stop-out experience on early employment diminishes over time and in some cases reverses.GiSeung Kim — The ‘Stop-out’ Experience and the Labor Market Performance · 5:32
The question sounds simple, but the research splits depending on what 'getting in' means. If you mean getting a job, experience often helps. If you mean getting into university, the picture is murkier, and some findings suggest experience can even work against you.
Start with the finding that cuts most directly against the obvious 'yes'. Rob Lilley [1] argues that legal workplace experience can be a barrier to entry, not a boost. That sounds odd until you think about who can afford unpaid or low-paid experience. If only some students can get it, requiring it filters people out rather than measuring talent. This is a fairness point as much as a skills point.
Other findings support the idea that experience matters, but for specific reasons. Claudio Labanca [25] found that firms preparing for export are much more likely to hire workers who already have experience at other exporting firms. That is a strong 'for': employers want people who have done the exact work before. Helen Dempsey [32] found that having less than three months of work in the first year was linked to an 8.5% increase in attrition, which suggests early work experience helps people stay and settle, not just get hired.
Then there are findings that complicate the story. Satoshi Araki [24] found that educational credentials matter more than high skills, so a highly skilled person without strong credentials is penalised. That is mixed for work experience: skills gained on the job may not be rewarded if the paperwork is missing. Zhiqi Wang [26] found that after controlling for academic performance, social class, gender, age and ethnicity, only one element significantly determined who got the best-paid job. That hints that background and credentials may outweigh experience in some labour markets. GiSeung Kim [7] found that the negative effect of taking a break from study on early employment fades over time and sometimes reverses, which is mixed: early gaps hurt, but not forever.
Why do researchers disagree? They study different countries, different groups (law students, exporters, graduates, early-career workers) and different outcomes (hiring, wages, staying in a job, university admission). A measure that predicts hiring in one sector may not predict wages in another. So the honest answer is not 'experience always matters' or 'it never does'. It matters most when it is directly relevant and when employers can see it, and it matters least when it becomes a gatekeeping hurdle that only some students can clear.