Careers & University / Big Questions / Worth it?
From the research interviews we hold · updated 09 Nov 2026
The research here points in different directions: some findings show degrees still pay off in earnings and life outcomes, while others show the earnings advantage shrinking and high skills mattering more than credentials. Whether a degree is worth it depends heavily on who you are, where you study, and what you want to do.
Word for word, from interviews with the researchers. Each opens the moment they say it.
The additional earnings from having a degree have decreased to nearly zero, while individuals still incur tens of thousands of pounds in debt.Hilary Cremin, University of Cambridge — Rewilding Education: Ecosystems, Inequality, and the Future of Schooling · 2:22Paper
High school graduates who do not attend college have lower life expectancy, lower earnings, lower satisfaction, and earn over a million dollars less than college graduates.William Tierney, University of Southern California — Academia, and the Battle for Higher Education · 18:37
Returns to educational credentials are significantly larger than returns to high skills, so that high credentials yield preferable labor market outcomes even without high skills, while highly skilled people without high credentials are penalized in the world of work.Satoshi Araki, Lingnan University — Economic Value of Credentials and Skills · 6:17
By age 30, the proportion of STEM and non-STEM graduates entering graduate-level, high-status managerial or professional jobs differs very little.Patrick White, University of Leicester — Where do all the STEM graduates go? · 13:24
Poorer students are more likely to drop out of university, both because the dropout rate is higher at lower tariff institutions and because poorer students are more likely to drop out than rich students within the same institution, with pressures and lack of academic preparation being possible reasons.Anna Vignoles, University of Cambridge — Widening Participation in Higher Education: A Quantitative Analysis · 4:56
Higher education institutions should expand their offerings beyond degree programs to include blended learning, online learning, certifications, small certificate programs, and small diploma programs, including degrees paired with internationally recognized certifications, because students are willing to pay for different kinds of programs.Sunitha Kshatriya, Aldar University — Building a Case of Diverse Knowledge Transfer in Higher Education between Finland and Dubai · 5:27
The question of whether a degree is worth it gets very different answers depending on which researchers you ask and what they measure. Some findings are strongly positive. [5] reports that high school graduates who skip college have lower life expectancy, lower earnings, and lower satisfaction, and earn over a million dollars less over a lifetime. That is a big, long-run gap, and it is the kind of evidence that has traditionally made the "yes" case. [15] adds a twist: credentials still beat raw skills in the labour market, so people with high skills but no degree are penalised, while people with strong credentials do well even without standout skills. That suggests the degree is doing real work as a signal, not just as a certificate of learning.
Other findings cut the other way. [1] says the extra earnings from a degree have fallen to nearly zero while students still take on tens of thousands of pounds of debt, which is a direct challenge to the financial case. [21] finds that by age 30, STEM and non-STEM graduates end up in graduate-level, high-status jobs at very similar rates, so the specific degree may matter less than people assume. [35] shows the picture is uneven: poorer students are more likely to drop out, partly because they attend lower-tariff institutions and partly because of pressures and preparation gaps within the same institution. That means the "worth it" calculation is not the same for everyone.
Why do researchers disagree? They are looking at different countries, different groups, and different time periods. [1] is about the UK and recent cohorts facing high fees; [5] is US data over a lifetime. [15] is about how employers reward credentials versus skills across societies, which is a structural question rather than a personal one. [6] points out that students increasingly want blended, online, and certificate options, so the traditional three-year degree is no longer the only route. [21] compares job status at a single age, while [5] tracks lifetime outcomes, and those two measures can tell different stories.
The honest summary is that the research does not give one answer. A degree looks valuable on average, especially for lifetime earnings and life outcomes, but the average hides big differences by institution, background, debt level, and field. The evidence supports thinking carefully about which degree, where, and at what cost, rather than treating "go to university" as automatically right or wrong.