Careers & University / Big Questions / Worth it?
From the research interviews we hold · updated 09 Nov 2026
The research here points in different directions, so there is no single answer: a degree still pays off in earnings and even lifespan, but the size of that payoff varies a lot by country, institution and family background, and debt carries real costs. Whether it is worth it depends heavily on what you study, where you study, and how much you have to borrow to do it.
Word for word, from interviews with the researchers. Each opens the moment they say it.
The additional earnings from having a degree have decreased to nearly zero, while individuals still incur tens of thousands of pounds in debt.Hilary Cremin, University of Cambridge — Rewilding Education: Ecosystems, Inequality, and the Future of Schooling · 2:22Paper
High school graduates who do not attend college have lower life expectancy, lower earnings, lower satisfaction, and earn over a million dollars less than college graduates.William Tierney, University of Southern California — Academia, and the Battle for Higher Education · 18:37
Reliance on debt may have had downsides that are not always appreciated, including making housing and education more expensive in the long run, adding extra fees for middlemen, and requiring annual interest payments to investors.Michael Glass, Boston College — Debt, Race, and the Suburban Dream: Michael Glass on the Hidden Inequalities Beneath America’s Postwar Boom · 2:55Paper
Poorer students are more likely to drop out of university, both because the dropout rate is higher at lower tariff institutions and because poorer students are more likely to drop out than rich students within the same institution, with pressures and lack of academic preparation being possible reasons.Anna Vignoles, University of Cambridge — Widening Participation in Higher Education: A Quantitative Analysis · 4:56
Whether higher education should be free tuition depends on the student, since students who are completely reliant on free tuition to access and graduate from higher education should receive it for free, while students who can pay part or all of their tuition fees should pay if they can because higher education institutions need this money.Ariane de Gayardon, University College London — Free Higher Education, Myths and Realities · 0:05
The findings split, and the split is informative. On the 'yes' side, [5] reports that people who skip college have lower life expectancy, lower earnings and lower life satisfaction, and earn over a million dollars less over a lifetime than graduates. That is a big gap, and it is the classic case for borrowing to get a degree. On the 'no' side, [1] finds that the extra earnings from a degree have fallen to nearly zero while students still take on tens of thousands of pounds of debt. If that is true where you live, the financial case for borrowing weakens sharply. [2] adds a structural worry: heavy reliance on debt can push up housing and education costs, add fees for middlemen, and lock borrowers into years of interest payments. So even a degree that pays off may pay off less than the headline figures suggest. Why would researchers disagree so sharply? Partly it is geography and time. [1] is looking at the UK, where tuition and debt levels are high; [5] draws on US lifetime data where the earnings premium has historically been very large. Different countries, different loan systems, different periods. Partly it is about who is being measured. [9] shows that poorer students are more likely to drop out, both because dropout is higher at lower-tariff institutions and because poorer students drop out more than richer ones within the same institution, citing pressure and weaker academic preparation. A debt-funded degree that is not finished is a very different bet from one that is. [4] makes a related point: whether tuition should be free depends on the student, since some need full support to access and finish, while others can pay and institutions need the money. That is a reminder that 'worth it' is not one calculation but many. The honest summary is that debt is a tool, not a verdict. It can buy access to a large lifetime premium, but the premium is uneven, the risk of not finishing is real, and the cost of borrowing is not trivial. The question is less 'is debt worth it' and more 'is this particular debt, for this particular course, at this particular institution, worth it for me'.