Careers & University / Big Questions / Getting in
From the research interviews we hold · updated 09 Nov 2026
Admissions tutors are not simply hunting for the highest test scores; the evidence suggests grades, self-awareness and reflective habits matter more. But the research disagrees on how much weight scores should carry, so a strong application shows both academic readiness and the ability to learn from feedback.
Word for word, from interviews with the researchers. Each opens the moment they say it.
Weighting test scores equally to or more strongly than high school GPAs in admission decisions means using weaker predictors of students' performance, which does not necessarily yield the candidates most likely to succeed in the program.Elaine Allensworth, University of Chicago — High School GPAs and ACT Scores as Predictors of College Completion · 10:24
SAT scores and standardized tests should be eliminated from college applications.Jonathan R. Cole, Columbia University — The Future of Great Universities · 4:52
Emphasizing standardized tests misses students who do not perform well on them and raises equity concerns because test performance differs by race and family income status, such that students with low test scores but stronger grades may be shut out of programs and schools despite being more likely to succeed than some students with higher test scores.Elaine Allensworth, University of Chicago — High School GPAs and ACT Scores as Predictors of College Completion · 11:13
In the final model, level of self-assessment and reference to professional standards had significant direct paths to GPA, while feedback-seeking and criteria-seeking were fully mediated through them.Ke Jiang, University of Auckland — Why intention drives self, assessment and academic performance · 8:28
Realignment through assessment changes the direction of a student's learning, and the poorest admissions come from students who have not grasped reflective practice as a means of influencing future behavior, instead reciting past events without considering how reflective learning might be helpful for future reference.Jenny Gibbons, University of York — Reflection, realignment and refraction · 6:19
Student success and retention are not determined by one factor alone but by a combination of key factors that can be evaluated early, such as in the first semester, to diagnose and support students in developing them.Chathurika Kannangara, University of Bolton — All That Glitters Is Not Grit · 6:29
The question assumes there is one checklist tutors use. The research suggests instead that tutors weigh different signals, and researchers disagree about which signals predict success. Start with the biggest disagreement: standardized tests. Allensworth [1] argues that weighting test scores equally to or more strongly than high school grades means using weaker predictors of how students will actually perform. Her second finding [9] goes further, warning that emphasizing tests shuts out students whose grades are strong but whose scores are low, and that test performance varies by race and family income. Cole [8] takes the strongest line, calling for SAT and standardized tests to be eliminated from applications altogether. These three point the same way: against treating admissions as a test-score contest. They come from US universities, where the SAT and similar tests are a live political issue, which helps explain the force of the claims.
Other findings point toward qualities a score cannot capture. Jiang [4] found that students' own self-assessment and their reference to professional standards had direct links to their grades, while seeking feedback and seeking criteria worked through those. In plain terms, students who can judge their own work and know what good practice looks like do better. Gibbons [6] adds that the weakest admissions are students who have not grasped reflective practice, who recite past events without asking how reflection could help them next time. For a tutor, that is a signal about how someone learns, not just what they know.
Kannangara [11] sits in the middle. Success and retention are not decided by one factor but by a combination of key factors that can be spotted early, such as in the first semester. That cuts against any single-number admissions rule, but it also means the relevant factors may only become visible after a student arrives, which is awkward for tutors choosing before entry.
Why the disagreement? The studies look at different countries, different levels of study, and different outcomes: grades, retention, or who gets in. Some measure what predicts university performance; others measure who is excluded. A tutor reading this evidence would reasonably look for grades plus evidence of reflection and self-awareness, while treating a single test score as one imperfect signal among several.