Careers & University / Big Questions / Choosing a subject
From the research interviews we hold · updated 09 Nov 2026
A career in medicine is less a single job than a long series of transitions — from student to trainee to independent clinician — and the research shows those transitions are where both the rewards and the strain concentrate. The findings here mostly agree that medicine demands continuous identity work, not just technical skill, and that support during change matters more than raw talent.
Word for word, from interviews with the researchers. Each opens the moment they say it.
Transitions constitute peculiar in-between zones of care that present health care workers with labor processes and conundrums different from those traditionally studied in typical settings, a phenomenon unexplored in studies of aging or medical sociology.Guillermina Altomonte, New York University — Exploiting Ambiguity · 1:02
Most pharmacists aspire to a clinician identity they cannot fully embody or enact, creating an identity dissonance.Jamie Kellar, University of Toronto — Professional identity in pharmacy · 5:10
New medical students may struggle with moral aversion to procedures such as hitting a person's leg with a hammer as a way of giving them a hip replacement, and may have to overcome this by recruiting habit learning mechanisms.Sian Chapman, University of Cumbria — The Four Horsemen of Economic Collapse · 7:55
Mentors must adapt to the changing personal and professional values of mentees, such as those that occur after having children, to provide relevant guidance throughout a career.Jarva Chow, University of Chicago — Why women in critical care still struggle to lead · 3:29
A global survey of movement disorders professionals found that gender-based career disparities are consistent across all geographic and economic contexts, indicating a systemic pattern.Veronica Bruno, University of Calgary — Gender and regional disparities in movement disorders: a global survey · 10:51
Brilliance in healthcare is perceived by clinicians as relating to a holistic approach and fluid interdisciplinary collaboration.Nick Hopwood, University of Technology Sydney — Paediatric tube-feeding: An agenda for care improvement and research · 9:41
Most people picture medicine as a fixed identity: you become a doctor and that is who you are. The research suggests it is more like a sequence of in-between states. Altomonte [3] argues that transitions — starting placements, moving between teams, moving from trainee to independent practice — are their own peculiar zones of care, with pressures that studies of ordinary clinical settings miss. That supports the obvious yes: medicine is a career defined by change, and the change is the hard part.
But two findings cut against the idea that the career simply delivers a stable professional self. Kellar [5] found that most pharmacists aspire to a clinician identity they cannot fully embody, producing what she calls identity dissonance. Chapman [16] describes new medical students struggling with moral aversion to procedures — the example given is jarring — and having to build habits to get past it. Both suggest the identity does not arrive ready-made; it is assembled, sometimes uncomfortably. That is a caution against imagining medicine as a smooth fit.
Other findings point back toward yes, but with conditions. Chow [14] shows mentors must adapt to mentees' changing values, such as after having children, if guidance is to stay relevant across a whole career. So the career is long, and the support has to move with it. Bruno [28] adds a structural note: a global survey found gender-based career disparities consistent across every geographic and economic context, which looks systemic rather than local. Hopwood [13] reports that clinicians themselves define brilliance as holistic and collaborative rather than individual and technical.
Why might these pull in different directions? They study different groups (pharmacists, medical students, movement-disorder specialists), different countries, and different measures — identity, career outcomes, perceptions of excellence. A pharmacist's blocked clinical role is not the same problem as a medical student's squeamishness or a specialist's career gap. Read together, they say the technical training is only part of it: the career is also a long negotiation with who you are becoming, and how much support you get during the switches shapes the experience as much as the science does.