Pancasila is the foundational philosophical theory and state ideology of Indonesia, first formulated by Sukarno in a speech delivered on 1 June 1945 during the first session of the Investigating Committee for Preparatory Work for Independence, known as the BPUPK.
Outline one reason why Sukarno proposed Pancasila on 1 June 1945.
Pancasila is the foundational philosophical theory and state ideology of Indonesia, first formulated by Sukarno in a speech delivered on 1 June 1945 during the first session of the Investigating Committee for Preparatory Work for Independence, known as the BPUPK. The name derives from two Sanskrit words, pañca meaning five and śīla meaning principles, and it was designed to provide the philosophical basis for an independent Indonesian state. Sukarno’s original formulation comprised five distinct principles: Kebangsaan Indonesia, or Indonesian nationalism, which stressed patriotism and the inclusion of all people living within the archipelago; Internasionalisme, or internationalism, which emphasised justice and the virtue of humanity; Musyawarah Mufakat, or deliberative consensus, which advocated a form of representative democracy where no ethnic group dominated and every council member held equal voting power; Kesejahteraan Sosial, or social welfare, which was premised on the theory of the welfare state and popular socialism; and Ketuhanan yang Berkebudayaan, a divinity that upholds religious freedom, a deliberately flexible formulation allowing both monotheism and polytheism to accommodate all of Indonesia’s major religions. In this speech, Sukarno explicitly rejected the name Panca Dharma, arguing that dharma meant obligation, whereas he was proposing principles rather than duties. He preferred the symbolic weight of the number five, drawing parallels to the Five Pillars of Islam, the five fingers on a hand, and the five senses, and he officially named his proposal Pancasila.
The formulation emerged directly from the context of Japanese occupation and the shifting fortunes of the Pacific War. Japan had invaded and occupied the Dutch East Indies in 1942, and following setbacks in the war, the Japanese promised future self-government for Indonesia. In September 1943, they established the Central Advisory Council in Java, chaired by the pre-war independence activist Sukarno. On 15 November 1944, at the fourth session of that council, Sukarno delivered a speech listing five guidelines for national life, which were produced by a committee he headed and dubbed the Five Obligations, or Panca Dharma. These obligations stipulated that Indonesia would remain a lifelong ally of Japan within the Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere, that a free Indonesian nation would be established with respect for Japanese assistance, that high morality and culture would be advanced, that eternal service would be given to the nation with devotion to Allah, and that eternal peace would be built based on the Japanese principle of Hakkō ichiu, meaning eight corners of the world under one roof. However, by the time the BPUPK was announced on 1 March 1945 by the Japanese 16th Army, Japan’s defeat was increasingly imminent, and Sukarno reframed these wartime obligations into Pancasila as a means of asserting Indonesian sovereignty and ideological independence. The first session of the BPUPK opened on 28 May 1945, and discussions on the basis for a future independent Indonesia began the following day, with various speakers putting forward proposals, including Wiranatakusumah, who suggested adopting the Panca Dharma. Sukarno’s speech on 1 June, later known as the Birth of Pancasila Address, represented a crucial compromise between advocates for an Islamic state and those for a secular state, aiming to unify Indonesia’s diverse religious and ethnic groups. He further proposed that the five principles could be compressed into three, or trisila, namely socio-nationalism, socio-democracy, and belief in God, and that these three could be further compressed into a single principle, or ekasila, which he called gotong royong, meaning mutual cooperation.
During the recess between the two BPUPK sessions, a Committee of Nine, known as the Panitia Sembilan, was formed to draft a preamble for the constitution incorporating Sukarno’s philosophy. This committee comprised Sukarno, Mohammad Hatta, Mohammad Yamin, Alexander Andries Maramis, Achmad Soebardjo, Ki Hadikusumo, Wahid Hasyim, Agus Salim, and Abikusno. Their draft became known as the Jakarta Charter. The committee rearranged the order of Sukarno’s original principles, moving the fifth sila regarding divinity to the first position, leaving the second sila in place, making the original first sila the third, and renumbering the original third and fourth principles as the fourth and fifth respectively. Sukarno accepted this revised structure. The first sila of the Jakarta Charter was originally formulated as Ketuhanan dengan kewajiban menjalankan syariat Islam bagi pemeluk-pemeluknya, meaning belief in God with the obligation for Muslim adherents to carry out Islamic law. However, on 18 August 1945, the Preparatory Committee for Indonesian Independence, known as the PPKI, deleted this clause obligating Islamic law, leaving the first sila simply as Ketuhanan Yang Maha Esa, or belief in the One and Only God, to ensure national unity. This final version, enshrined in the fourth paragraph of the preamble of the Constitution of Indonesia, comprises five principles: Belief in the One and Only God, Just and Civilized Humanity, The Unity of Indonesia, Democratic Life Led by Wisdom of Thoughts in Deliberations Amongst Representatives of the People, and Social Justice for All the People of Indonesia. The compromise was critical, as it prevented fragmentation between secular nationalists and Islamic groups, allowing the proclamation of independence on 17 August 1945. The subsequent adoption of liberal democracy during the parliamentary era from 1949 to 1955 tested Pancasila’s implementation, as competing political parties interpreted the principles differently, leading to instability that Sukarno later used to justify the introduction of Guided Democracy. Contemporary research, such as that by Badrun and colleagues in 2023, has found that Pancasila’s acculturation through local traditions and practices involving various stakeholders encourages acceptance of diversity and prevents religious extremism in Indonesia.
In CAIE A-Level examinations, Pancasila appears in questions about Japanese occupation policies, Indonesian independence movements, and post-colonial state-building. Students must evaluate whether Pancasila was a genuine philosophical foundation or a pragmatic political tool designed to unite factions. The key argument is that Sukarno’s principles successfully balanced religious and secular demands, but their vagueness allowed later authoritarian interpretations. A common mistake is to treat Pancasila as static; students should instead analyse its evolution from the 1944 Panca Dharma through the 1945 Jakarta Charter to the final constitution, noting how each change reflected shifting power dynamics. The exam angle often requires assessing the extent to which Pancasila achieved national unity versus serving Sukarno’s personal political ambitions. To earn full marks, candidates should trace the precise sequence of events, name the Committee of Nine members, and explain the significance of the 18 August 1945 deletion, while an effective evaluation point is that the removal of the Islamic law clause was both a unifying gesture and a source of lasting tension with Islamist groups, demonstrating that Pancasila’s compromises created new political fault lines even as they resolved old ones.
Use Badrun et al. as a positive case, then weigh it against Barton et al.'s evidence of Islamic contestation to judge the limits of authoritarian reinterpretation.
Barton, Yılmaz and Morieson (2021) chart the contestation of Islamic religious ideas in Indonesian politics from 1945 to 2001, showing how Islamic civil society groups and intellectuals have played a vital role in shaping political outcomes.
The thesis claims Pancasila's ambiguity permitted authoritarian reinterpretations, but this paper shows that Islamic civil society groups actively contested and constrained such reinterpretations, limiting how far authoritarianism could go.
A strong evaluation sentence might look like: 'While the thesis argues that Pancasila's deliberate ambiguity permitted authoritarian reinterpretations, Barton, Yılmaz and Morieson (2021) demonstrate that Islamic civil society groups and intellectuals actively contested political developments throughout the 20th century, suggesting that ambiguity also enabled democratic resistance rather than merely facilitating authoritarianism.'
Faith, Liberty, and Conscription in the American Revolution
Dja Dja Wurrung Voices and the Hidden History of Australia's Gold Rushes
Caste, Labour and the Silent Rebellion of Subaltern Education
How Holocaust Trials Moved From the Margins to the Center
York's Jews and the Making of Civic Institutions in Medieval England
Holocaust Appropriation in Anti-Lockdown Protests: False Equivalence and Historical Harm
Droidean Corporeal Horror: Star Wars and the Error of Modern Mastery
Empress Deng Sui and Eastern Han Gender Norms: Rethinking Female Rule
Ten Australians Who Challenged White Australia's Racial Consensus
The Inscrutable Jailbreak of Clément Barbot: Dogs, Terror, and Memory in Hispaniola
Reconstructing Australia's Earliest Category 5 Cyclone and 1881 Storm Surge
White Collar Crime Before the Term Existed in Nineteenth Century America
Undine Spragg: The Worst Mother in American Literature?
Archaeology, Nationalism and Race: How the Past Fuels Exclusionary Politics
The paper argues that Civic Education in Indonesia must be based on Pancasila values in all aspects of citizenship learning. It concludes that Pancasila serves as the philosophical foundation and defining characteristic of Indonesian civic education.
▲ The study relies solely on a literature review method, which limits its ability to provide empirical evidence on how Pancasila values are actually implemented in practice.
Read the paper →The paper argues that previous research on Indonesia as a welfare state focused only on legislation, whereas this study examines the philosophical basis derived from the thoughts of Indonesia's founding fathers.
▲ The study's scope is limited to philosophical analysis and does not examine how these founding fathers' ideas translate into actual legal or policy outcomes.
Read the paper →The paper charts the contestation of Islamic religious ideas in Indonesian politics from 1945 to 2001, focusing on Modernist, Traditionalist, and neo-Modernist intellectual streams. It examines their relationships with Muhammadiyah and Nahdlatul Ulama, their political influence, and their interactions with the state.
▲ The study's temporal scope ends in 2001, which limits its ability to address the significant political and religious developments in Indonesia over the past two decades.
Read the paper →The paper concludes that the principles of material content in Law No. 12/2011 contain Pancasila values, but not all Pancasila values are included. Specifically, the values from the principle of Belief in One Almighty God are not yet contained in these principles.
▲ The study is limited to a normative legal analysis of a single law, which restricts its generalisability to other Indonesian laws or to the actual implementation of Pancasila values in practice.
Read the paper →The paper argues that Pancasila's values are rooted in the real values of Indonesia's plural society, including Balinese local wisdom. It focuses on exploring Balinese local wisdom values that align with Pancasila to strengthen national insight.
▲ The study's focus on Balinese local wisdom alone limits its generalisability to other regions of Indonesia with different cultural traditions and local wisdom.
Read the paper →