Core theme · compulsory
Knowledge and the knower
The compulsory core theme: who we are as knowers, how our perspectives and communities shape what we know, and when we should trust others' knowledge.
48 clips
The goal in certain inquiries is not knowledge of an answer but a stronger epistemic standing, such as certainty or higher confidence.
So I think here, you know, the answer to the question and what you're after is not knowledge of the answer, but instead some sort of deeper or sort of stronger epistemic standing, namely some, some kind of certainty or a higher degree of confidence in the answer.
Arianna Falbo
Bentley University
Any act of knowledge involves both a knower and a known, so focusing only on the known may cause one to miss something.
but we also wanna attend to ourselves as knowers, you know? So in any act of knowledge, there is a knower and there's a known, and, and so if you focus only on the known, you may be missing something.
Timothy P. Muldoon
Boston College
Knowledges that originate from within a community, including specialized expert knowledges, have political potential.
And that has a political potential in my view, because it comes from within the community, it comes from knowledges that the communities hold as a whole. But of course, these communities also have experts. They also have practitioners who are specialized in certain knowledges, medical knowledges, or any other kinds of knowledges.
Madhulika Banerjee
University of Delhi
It may be possible to know ourselves better by examining the intricate beauty of the world and understanding ourselves as part of it.
I think it's possible to know ourselves better by examining the world around us and all it's amazing and intricate beauty and understanding ourselves as a part of it.
Laura Reece Hogan
St. John's Seminary in Camarillo
Learning is not only an individual mental process but a collective phenomenon that occurs in communities and is directly related to practice.
second lesson is about learning that learning is not just it is but not only that occurs in the minds of people but it is a collective phenomena that occurs in communities and it is directly related to practice.
Emanuel Adler
University of Toronto
Ideas can become accepted as truth through repeated reproduction, regardless of their veracity, and consulting diverse sources is a corrective strategy.
Because what seems to be happening, Sam, is that we end up with, ideas becoming, if you like, reproduced and reproduced to the stage where it becomes the truth, even though it might not be. So how do you do about that? You look for different sources.
Geoffrey Lawrence
University of Queensland
A deceptively simple understanding of an experience must be abandoned in favor of recognizing a confusing and possibly paralyzing complexity of many interrelated factors.
My sense is that's what I call a deceptively simple understanding of an experience. My sense is we need to go through another stage, which is letting go of that deceptively simple understanding to what I call confusing and possibly paralyzing complexity, to recognize that there are many interrelated factors
Stuart Hill
Western Sydney University
A model that fosters meaningful cognitive connections between new information and previously learned knowledge is needed.
the meaningful cog cognitive connections. So we need to emphasize a model that addresses meaningful cognitive connections between the new information or the conceptions that are really acquired. So there is a need to have this meaningful connections. There is a need to connect the new information to previously learned knowledge.
Rola Khishfe
American University of Beirut
A more expanded view of epistemic communities is particularly important to add practice to knowledge to understand epistemic communities as a mechanism of how international relations change.
A more expanded view of epistemic communities and I would add here is particularly important to add practice to knowledge Empower would be to understand epistemic communities as a mechanism of how international relations change.
Emanuel Adler
University of Toronto
Information theory offers a different and extremely useful way to look at the foundations of probabilistic statements.
was that information theory offers a different and extremely useful way to look at the foundations of probabilistic statements.
Ioannis Kontoyiannis
University of Cambridge
Modern approaches to recognition are based on a false premise.
And the conclusion really has to be that modern approaches to recognition are based on the false premise.
Peter Hall
University of Bath
The central problem is not that pivotal researchers possess knowledge, but how to distribute that knowledge into practice.
And contrary to what most people were saying then, the, the idea was then there are pivotal researchers who have the knowledge and then pose the question, how do we distribute this to practice?
Andrew Hargreaves
Boston College
Pupils acquire powerful knowledge, the knowledge associated with research and new knowledge.
If you want pupils to acquire what I call, what some of us would call powerful knowledge, the knowledge associated with research, new knowledge and so forth.
Michael Young
UCL Institute of Education
Theories are far more shallow than expected, and people who can explain how things work may do so quite well yet exhibit surprising incompetence.
more duplicate because theories were like and discovered to my surprise that they were far more shallow than I thought and that they thought and so that the illusion is if someone explain what things work whether it's a zipper or flush toilet or any number of things they might conflicting they can do so quite well and then there are disaster and honestly, I've often very surprised at their own incompetence.
Frank Keil
Yale University
Combining various lines of evidence yields conclusions about the nature of reality and how the brain works.
But when we look at all the these various lines of evidence and we put them together, we come to a number of conclusions about the nature of reality and how the brain works. And so we here's what we proposed.
Mario Beauregard
Arizona State University
Being incapable of knowing is a more rigorous test than simply knowing.
The difficulty is simply that the expression incapable of knowing is a higher test than simply knowing.
Warren Brookbanks
Auckland University of Technology
Disparate individual accounts of a subject's behavior, though seemingly separate, are in fact entangled and interconnected.
I, I took all these separate bits of data, but was able to see how entangled mixed up connected all of the accounts were. So that, although if people were trying to say parents, teachers were trying to explain Catherine's behavior at school, everybody had their own account of that.
Valerie Walkerdine
Cardiff University
Existing work overlooks the role of policy uncertainty.
In my opinion, what they are missing is the uncertainties, what they call policy uncertainty.
Francesco Maria Esposito
University of Birmingham
The flow of information generates dynamics that tend to push people into a state of law uncertainty, an insight into behavior overlooked by psychologists.
certain insights into people's behavior that psychologists appear to have overlooked. Namely the Dynamics generated by the flow of information has got the tendency of pushing people into a state of law uncertainty.
University of Surrey
Over-identification with a projected image of who we are can lead to alienation from our authentic sense of self in the context of doing research.
Phantom we thought we used a board to kind of say well, is it the case also that because we've become so bought into this image this projected image of who we are we become alienated from a sense of ourselves in the context of doing research.
Richard Watermeyer
University of Bristol
Dominance of one epistemology constrains trust research by limiting it to one particular way of doing research, whereas trust's multidisciplinary and novel development makes the ability to use a variety of research philosophies and their associated methods important.
Niamh, myself and our other colleagues, argue that this dominance on one epistemology can be constraining for the future of trust research as it tends to mean that research is done in one particular way. You may think this isn't the problem, but with an area such as trust which is multidisciplinary and also one which is developing in new and novel ways, the ability to use a variety of different research philosophies and then their associated methods is really important.
Mark NK Saunders
University of Birmingham
Unfitting in relation to knowledge is performed.
And what these have led me to think about and that's been the sort of second body of work has been how to perform unfitting in relation to knowledge.
Irit Rogoff
Goldsmiths University of London
As relationships among people become more complicated, the knowledge required also becomes more complicated.
the more complicated, the relationship among people are, the more complicated the knowledge that is required. For example, even setting up this meeting, I really couldn't do that, but there was a time, and I can still write and read very well, but not this.
Tamar Frankel
Boston University
The young person can neither be conceptualized nor represented outside the conditions of shared histories, experiences, and relational circumstances, as proposed as a scientific first principle.
and we propose as a scientific first principle that the young person can neither be conceptualized nor represented outside the conditions of shared histories, experiences, and relational circumstances.
Tom Billington
University of Sheffield
Systemic and interpersonal perspectives are combined.
And my work combines both this systemic and interpersonal perspectives.
Jessica T. DeCuir-Gunby
University of Southern California
Theorizing is a real-world practice that people actually do, rather than something that should conform to a guidebook or rule book.
So this, the, the idea to behind the paper was to try and break away from the textbook, the cookbook approach to theorizing, and to try and think of it as a real thing that happens in the world that people actually do, rather than something that should conform to a, a, a, a sort of guidebook or a rule book given to you by the methodology teachers.
Christopher Collinge
University of Birmingham
Acknowledging one's own ignorance is epistemically important because without awareness of lacking knowledge, one may not pursue truth at all.
Novo own ignorance was important for at least three reasons. The first is an epistemic concern, a concern about knowledge, which is we ought to live in the pursuit of the truth because, if we don't know that we already lack knowledge, so we may not pursue it at all.
Marina McCoy
Boston College
The present and future determine whether past errors and successes are correctly understood and can inform future evaluations of learning.
le présent et le futur sont garants du poste est ce qu'on va bien comprendre les erreurs qu'on a fait dans le passé, parce qu'on va comprendre les bon coup qu'on a fait dans le passé, puis comment va pouvoir les amener à créune évaluation des apprentissages du futur.
Eric Frenette
University of Laval
Inquiry can aim not only at knowledge but also at other epistemic benefits, such as desirable positions resulting from investigation.
I had to defend a position on which inquiry can aim among other things. it can aim at knowledge, but it can also aim at other kinds of, of sort of epistemic goodies, like kinds of, positions we might wanna be in as a result of asking an investigating question.
Arianna Falbo
Bentley University
Membership fluidity is a previously overlooked dimension in the literature, which had focused on knowledge flow rather than the movement of people.
the second thing is we add this, this idea of membership fluidity, right? I mean, that, that really hadn't been thought of in this literature. We, we thought a lot about, as I said, knowledge flowing in and out, but we didn't necessarily think about the people side as much.
Brian Fox
Bentley University

Education extends beyond formal schooling to include equipping individuals to navigate the 'in between space' of oppositions by understanding and connecting them.
education is more than schools and schooling, you know, we have National systems of schooling, but what's really important is that Humans face predicaments where they have to deal with these oppositions and actually the extent to which their resourced within that in between space so that they understand the opposition and connect accordingly, you
Terri Seddon
La Trobe University
Two parties share a common concern about the consequences of the knowledge they impart.
What they share in common is they're both concerned about what will happen with the knowledge that you impart. That's what they have in common.
Mark Nichter
University of Arizona
Thinking about learning becomes more complex in a graduated way, but it remains intuitive at all stages.
So it's, it says as if there is a graduation where, where thinking about learning becomes more and more complex, it remains in all these, these stages rather intuitive.
Martijn Meeter
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
Players' behaviors can be measured to determine whether they align with a game's intended epistemic purpose, specifically whether the game changes their state of knowledge.
And what we've been able to do is quantify how players approach the game. So it's really all about measuring behaviors. We try to measure whether behavior aligns to the game's intended epistemic purpose. So does the game change their state of knowledge?
Dave Gould
University of Western Australia
When an individual's views are close to a point of no uncertainty, Bayesian flow tends to move them toward that state of certainty.
And it turns out that if your views are close to one of these points with no uncertainty, then the Bayesian flow traps you in that neighborhood in the sense that there's a strong tendency to try to move you towards that state of no uncertainty. Okay?
Dorje Brody
University of Surrey
If a principle is viable, it is true and known by the knower, which supports a more realistic conception of knowledge.
Well then I could say, I, I think it's fair to say that if it's, if it's viable, that principle is true and known by you. And part of the argument for that is to have a more realistic sense of knowledge more generally.
Aaron Zimmerman
University of California Santa Barbara
The ready acceptance of the idea that minds could be multiply realized is challenged.
I wrote a paper in 2000 and, and subsequently, co-authored a bunch of work with a philosopher named Tom Bulger and, and we're challenging the ready acceptance of this idea that minds could be multiply, realized.
Larry Shapiro
University of Wisconsin Madison
Getting students to engage with knowledge is about transforming who they are and how they engage with the world, and universities have an educational responsibility to design experiences that convey what this knowledge can do for students and who they can become.
So as I said, for me, it's really about the ways in which we get students to engage with knowledge. And what we're trying to do with that engagement and knowledge is to transform who the students are and to transform their way of engaging with the world. And that from a university's perspective is about designing a set of experiences that brings our understanding about and also says to the student, look. If you study with us, if you engage with this knowledge, this is who you're gonna become. This is what you can do in the world. Not because that should set limits on what students can achieve, but because we have an educational responsibility. If we're saying to students, come and study with us. Look what this knowledge can do for you, then we need to know that is actually where we expect that knowledge to lead students.
Paul Wiliam Ashwin
Lancaster University
Learning in fabricated realities requires rethinking valid knowledge
the next chapter in learning and interpretation and sense-making and inferential interpretation really becomes to no longer learn from the challenge when to uncover a hidden truth like we did in the crypto paper, but to deal with the challenge of what if there's not a stable truth or a stable reality at all.
Claus Rerup
Frankfurt School
Ethnographically and conceptually accounting for the generic 'hopefully' allows people to examine the hierarchies of what is important in their social worlds.
And I, I think to think about the generic hopefully, to Ethnographically account for it and to conceptually account for it affords people a space to, to think about really what are the hierarchies of what is important to us in thinking about the social worlds we inhabit.
Scott MacLochlainn
Johns Hopkins University
A latent calling is a felt but unanswered calling toward one's work that is held within one's repertoire of identities and primed to reemerge when the timing is right.
However, we've added this idea of a latent calling to this sort of repertoire of different types of abandoned callings and, and What we've defined a latent calling as is a calling that, we feel, towards our work that goes unanswered, but it's held within our repertoire of identities primed to reemerge when the timing is right.
Katie Bailey
King's College London

Scientific knowledge is based on and derived from observation in the natural world but also on reasons other than observational and experimental evidence, as illustrated by centuries of observing pendulum motion without figuring it out.
Other questions, getting back to my concern about saying that all scientific knowledge has to be derived from observation, I ask the question, to what extent is scientific knowledge based on and or derived from observation in the natural world? But then I ask, in what ways is it based on reasons other than observational and experimental evidence? Because when you're teaching about pendulum motion, a teacher who wants the students to deeply understand it has to raise the idea that people had been looking at how pendulum moved for centuries and they couldn't figure it out.
Michael Clough
Texas A M University
The writing process itself is also the creation of new knowledge.
it's that writing process itself is also the creation of new knowledge.
Judy Williams
Monash University
Greater knowledge decreases the probability of taking action.
The, the more you know, the less likely you are to act,
Aaron Sachs
Cornell University
Selective memory of self-confirming information reinforces and solidifies existing self-narratives, making them more rigid and constraining.
what actually happens is the information that helps you to confirm things you already think about yourself is the stuff that gets remembered. And that just, functions to make that concrete harder. We look for things to confirm the stories about ourselves, and then we become more entrenched and more imprisoned by them.
Nic Hooper
Cardiff University
Theory choice often involves a trade-off between a theory that better fits perceptions and discourse and one that, despite fitting less well, offers more distinctive insights.
And my comment in the article was that very often what we have to do is we have to choose between possible theories, one of which better fits, has a better fit with our perceptions, a better fit with the way we talk about something, has a better fit as against a theory which may fit less well. But though it fits less well, it has something more distinctive to say.
Brian Bix
University of Minnesota
Understanding humanity requires not merely recognizing individuals but analyzing the fundamental structures of relationships that generate meaning.
So it's not just nodding to the person and recognizing them, but it's actually trying to understand the, the very makings of relations that give meaning, to our understanding of humanity.
Nergis Canefe
York University
A hybrid use of the concept outside positive and normative ideas is proposed, where a reasonable person in certain situations would have seen bias.
the first thing that, we propose a hybrid use of the concept that is outside the positive and normative ideas, right? And we also want that we believe that the reasonable person in situations such as Alex Hall, Barton and Chubb or Newcastle would have seen bias because it would've fought.
Leonardo Oliveira
Royal Holloway University of London