Economics is a social science, meaning it is a disciplined, evidence-based field of study that focuses on human behaviour within the context of scarcity.
Explain one reason why economics is considered a social science rather than a natural science.
Weigh the evidence on performativity and methodology against Smith's experimental findings to assess the model's limitations and applicability.
Vernon L. Smith (1994) argues that laboratory experiments in economics are feasible and have produced findings such as institutions mattering, optimization not requiring conscious calculation, and fairness influencing outcomes.
The thesis claims controlled experiments are impossible in economics, but Smith demonstrates that laboratory experiments are not only possible but yield refutable implications that challenge core assumptions like rational calculation and perfect information.
A strong evaluation sentence might look like: "While the thesis states that controlled experiments are impossible in economics, Smith (1994) shows that laboratory experiments can test market behaviour under controlled conditions, revealing that optimization often occurs without conscious calculation, which challenges the assumption that scarcity-driven rational choice is the universal foundation of economic behaviour."
Integrating economics with politics, psychology, and history can move toward a unified social science that encompasses both the general and the particular.
Economics analyzes the impact of shocks to a system, whereas questions of good versus bad or right versus wrong belong to philosophers and ultimately politicians.
Ecological economics defines the economy as a social metabolism, analyzing flows of energy and materials rather than monetary or labor-value categories.
Narrative theory and economic science can work together to reveal the fictionalized elements and assumptions built into economic models.
The evolution of economics is a complex process that responds to internal factors, not a simple refinement of vague theories.
The core laws of an economic system are determined by psychophysical laws concerning mind-matter interaction, not by physics or engineering.
Theory and mathematics can inform us about the likely long-term consequences of the world we live in, as economics is adept at describing future equilibria.
The public evaluates the economy using a broader set of criteria than economists, including social and moral considerations, whereas economists focus solely on efficiency.
A major error of modern economics is its near-exclusive focus on competition and individual maximization.
Economic debates and policy are deeply political, contradicting the discipline's self-image as a scientific, non-normative, and non-ideological field.
Street Art, Virtual Space and the Wellbeing of Public Culture
Syria's Economic Reintegration After Assad: Trade Data and Regional Dynamics
New Zealand's Energy History and the Case Against New LNG Investment
Does Education Increase Voter Turnout and Independent Registration?
Does Family Policy Change Birth Timing or Fertility Rates?
Utah Cares: State Cooperative Health Plan and Economic Growth
Measuring Welfare, Relevant Growth in Structural Transformation Economies
Intrinsic Motivation and Ethnic Minority Representation in UK Parliament
Network Neutrality: The Battle Over Internet Traffic and Control
India's 2008 Delimitation: Was Redistricting Politically Neutral?
Mexico's 2021 Outsourcing Ban: Labor Share, Markdowns and Fiscal Evasion
How Wealthy Taxpayers Exploit Asset Classification Ambiguity to Hide Wealth
How voters' evaluation of the economy influences the behavior of the governments and thus their economic performance
Subjective Earnings Risk: Why Job Transitions and Match Quality Matter
Hawkins (1945) argues that economic theory, like philosophy, relies heavily on methodology and conceptual analysis, but that borrowing methods from physical science is insufficient for social science. The paper suggests that social science needs to develop its own new concepts and structures, and that some philosophers even deny the possibility of a strict social science.
▲ The paper is a theoretical and methodological discussion without empirical evidence or case studies to support its claims about the limitations of borrowing from physical science.
Read the paper →Mackenzie, Muniesa, and Siu (2007) explore the controversial idea that economics can be performative, meaning it sometimes creates the very economic phenomena it claims to analyze. The book uses accessible case studies to provide concrete evidence for this concept of performativity in economics.
▲ The study relies on selected case studies, which may not be representative of all economic contexts, limiting the generalisability of its findings on performativity.
Read the paper →Searle (2005) reflects on how economics was taught as a natural science, with theories like savings equals investment presented as scientific laws similar to physics equations. The author implies that this approach may have overlooked the distinct nature of economic subject matter.
▲ The paper is a personal reflection based on the author's undergraduate experience, lacking systematic empirical analysis or a representative sample of economics education.
Read the paper →Fourcade, Ollion, and Algan (2015) find that economics holds a dominant position among US social sciences, characterized by insularity, hierarchical structure, and better material conditions for economists. They argue that economists' objective supremacy is linked to their individualist worldviews and confidence in their discipline's problem-solving ability.
▲ The study focuses exclusively on the United States, so its findings about economists' superiority may not apply to other countries or academic systems.
Read the paper →Smith (1994) reviews findings from laboratory experiments in economics, showing that institutions (rules of exchange) matter, optimization is not from conscious calculation, less information can be better, and fairness depends on tastes or expectations. The paper also discusses how experiments contribute to understanding how economic systems work.
▲ The findings are based on laboratory experiments, which may not fully replicate real-world economic behaviour due to artificial settings and small participant samples.
Read the paper →