John Neville Keynes, in his seminal 1917 work *The Scope and Method of Political Economy*, formalised a critical distinction between economic science and applied economics, a framework that continues to shape the discipline’s methodological self-understanding.
Outline one reason why J.N. Keynes argued that applied economics should replace the term 'art of political economy'.
An article argued that there is a common theme in both Keynes' work and in the work of Marx.
Integrating economics with politics, psychology, and history can move toward a unified social science that encompasses both the general and the particular.
A jointly edited handbook, the Handbook of Historical Economics, published by Academic Press in 2021, contributes to a better understanding of the methodological cleavage between economic historians and economists when they look at historical economics.
Economic debates and policy are deeply political, contradicting the discipline's self-image as a scientific, non-normative, and non-ideological field.
Converting broad economic principles into operational policy frameworks requires non-self-evident, non-purely-technical choices about models, assumptions, and scaling parameters that take positions on political economy and rest on a priori normatively informed assumptions about how efficiently markets operate and how likely they are to restore full employment and equilibrium.
As an interdisciplinary field, this field needs the collection of the skills and abilities of both economic historians and economists, economists with data and statistical techniques and historians with more careful analysis of sources.
Economics analyzes the impact of shocks to a system, whereas questions of good versus bad or right versus wrong belong to philosophers and ultimately politicians.
Narrative theory and economic science can work together to reveal the fictionalized elements and assumptions built into economic models.
The book lays surer foundations for conceptualizing the most important institution of modern economic life and for understanding how that institution has become politicized.
The core laws of an economic system are determined by psychophysical laws concerning mind-matter interaction, not by physics or engineering.
Street Art, Virtual Space and the Wellbeing of Public Culture
Syria's Economic Reintegration After Assad: Trade Data and Regional Dynamics
New Zealand's Energy History and the Case Against New LNG Investment
Does Education Increase Voter Turnout and Independent Registration?
Does Family Policy Change Birth Timing or Fertility Rates?
Utah Cares: State Cooperative Health Plan and Economic Growth
Measuring Welfare, Relevant Growth in Structural Transformation Economies
Intrinsic Motivation and Ethnic Minority Representation in UK Parliament
Network Neutrality: The Battle Over Internet Traffic and Control
India's 2008 Delimitation: Was Redistricting Politically Neutral?
Mexico's 2021 Outsourcing Ban: Labor Share, Markdowns and Fiscal Evasion
How Wealthy Taxpayers Exploit Asset Classification Ambiguity to Hide Wealth
How voters' evaluation of the economy influences the behavior of the governments and thus their economic performance
Subjective Earnings Risk: Why Job Transitions and Match Quality Matter
Friedman (2009) argues that economics should be treated as a positive science focused on 'what is', separate from normative questions about 'what ought to be'. He warns that confusing these two approaches has led to serious errors in economic thinking.
▲ The essay presents a philosophical argument rather than empirical evidence, so its claims about the consequences of confusing positive and normative economics are not tested against real-world data.
Read the paper →Keynes (1891) shows that disagreements over the scope and method of political economy have often been exaggerated because the true nature of opposing views is misunderstood. He presents both sides of these controversies fairly without trying to fully reconcile them.
▲ The analysis is limited to late-19th-century debates in British political economy, so its conclusions may not apply to modern economic methodology or non-Western traditions.
Read the paper →Harcourt (2001) describes John Maynard Keynes as the gifted eldest child of John Neville Keynes, born into a professional Cambridge household in 1883. It notes that John Neville Keynes wrote two minor classics on logic and political economy and was a colleague of Alfred Marshall.
▲ The biographical focus on Keynes's family background and personal relationships does not provide systematic evidence for how these factors shaped his economic theories.
Read the paper →Robinson (1969) reviews Leijonhufvud's book which distinguishes between Keynesian economics and the economics of Keynes himself as a study in monetary theory. The review appears in The Economic Journal and discusses the book's contribution to understanding Keynes's monetary thought.
▲ As a single book review, it represents one scholar's critical assessment rather than an original empirical study, limiting its ability to independently verify Leijonhufvud's claims.
Read the paper →Blaug (1963) presents a history of economic theory from Adam Smith to Keynes that focuses strictly on theoretical analysis rather than historical digressions. It includes detailed Reader's Guides to major texts to encourage students to engage directly with original works by economists like Smith, Ricardo, and Marx.
▲ The selection of only nine major texts may overlook important contributions from non-Western economists or less canonical figures, potentially narrowing the scope of theoretical analysis presented.
Read the paper →